Article
When to Refinish Vs Replace a Door
10 Steps to Decide if Refinishing is Worth It
Deciding whether to refinish or replace a door depends on several key factors: condition, material, cost, aesthetic goals, and functionality. Here’s a breakdown to help you decide:
Refinish a Door If:
1. The Door is Structurally Sound
- No warping, major cracks, or rotting (for wood doors).
- No broken internal components (for metal or composite doors).
2. Surface Damage is Cosmetic
- Scratches, fading, peeling paint, or minor dents.
- You just want a new look (e.g., change of stain or paint color).
3. You Have a Solid Wood or High-Quality Door
- Solid wood doors are excellent candidates for refinishing.
- Fiberglass doors can also often be repainted or restained.
4. Budget is a Concern
- Refinishing is usually cheaper (often 1/3 to 1/2 the cost of replacement).
5. You Want to Preserve Architectural Style
- Especially important in older homes with custom or antique doors.
Replace a Door If:
1. It's Warped, Cracked, or Rotted
- Structural damage or water intrusion is usually not worth repairing.
2. Poor Insulation or Energy Efficiency
- Old doors might leak air; newer models have better seals and insulation.
3. Hardware is Failing and Cannot Be Repaired
- Hinges, locks, or framing issues that cause sticking or misalignment.
4. The Material is Not Worth Refinishing
- Hollow-core doors, some metal doors, or cheaper veneers don’t refinish well.
5. You're Doing a Major Renovation
- Replacing a door might better match new windows, siding, or style updates.
Cost Comparison (General Ranges):
- Refinishing: $100-$400 (DIY or Professional)
- Replacement: $500-$2500+ (depending on material, labor, and style)
Pro Tip:
If you’re unsure, get quotes for both. A contractor or carpenter can tell you if your existing door is a good candidate for refinishing or if it’s past the point of saving.